EO Study: A Violent Sun Affects Earth's Ozone

From July 14 to 16, 2000, the surface of the sun exploded. Huge, bright flares spewed out into space like powerful fountains colorfully lit from beneath. Within a few hours, the solar storm bombarded Earth with a shower of positively-charged hydrogen atoms, called protons, causing scientific and communications satellites to short-circuit. Through a series of chemical reactions in our atmosphere, the protons drastically diminished the upper-most areas of the ozone layer, a protective blanket mostly in the stratosphere that blocks life-threatening ultraviolet radiation from reaching the Earth. This shower of protons, known by solar science insiders as the Bastille Day event, was the third largest of its kind in the last 30 years.
For more information, movies, and high-resolution images visit ISTP Sun-Earth Connection Event, July 14–16, 2000, and Hot Shots from SOHO, July 14, 2000.

Image of the Flare from TRACE

Atmospheric scientist Charles Jackman and a team of researchers from NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center and Hampton University in Virginia recognized a rare opportunity to gather further proof that solar storms destroy ozone. They already knew that when protons bombard the upper atmosphere, they break up molecules of gases like nitrogen and water vapor. Once freed, those products readily react with ozone molecules and reduce the ozone layer. So, Jackman and his colleagues recalled specific Northern Hemisphere atmospheric data from NASA and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) satellites that continuously monitor the composition of gases and molecules that surround our planet.

Their findings, published in the August 1, 2001, issue of Geophysical Research Letters, show that less than one percent of total atmospheric ozone in the Northern Hemisphere can be quickly reduced by one of these events. “It is an indication of the power of the sun to actually affect the atmosphere in a sudden, cataclysmic way,” Jackman says. While the results do not show a significant impact on human health, especially considering that most of the ozone loss documented in this study occurs over the northern polar region, they are important scientifically. The study gives detailed and quantified knowledge of how a solar storm affects upper-level ozone. As scientists race to better understand humankind’s role in ozone loss, they must first be able to tease out the natural causes.

On July 14th, 2000, an active region of the sun (called AR9077) produced a massive flare. The event also blasted an enormous cloud of positive-charged particles toward planet Earth, triggering magnetic storms and dramatic auroral displays. This striking close-up of AR9077 was made by the orbiting Transition Region and Coronal Explorer (TRACE) satellite shortly after the flare erupted. Suspended in an arcade of magnetic loops, the image shows a one million degree hot solar plasma cooling down. Plasma is a gas that has been heated to a state where it contains ions and free-floating electrons. The false-color image covers an expansive 230,000 by 77,000 kilometer area on the Sun’s surface (Earth’s diameter is about 12,800 kilometers) and was recorded in extreme ultraviolet light. Collectively resembling a popular “slinky” toy, the enormous loops are actually magnetic field lines which trap the glowing, cooling plasma above the relatively dark solar surface. After the flare, AR9077’s activity decayed as it was carried farther across the Earth-facing hemisphere of the Sun by solar rotation. Active regions like AR9077 appear as groups of dark sunspots in visible light. (Image courtesy TRACE)

Total Ozone-July 15, 2000

“A lot of impacts on ozone, like those caused by humans, are very subtle and happen over long periods of time,” says Jackman. “But when these solar proton events occur you can see immediately a change in the atmosphere.”

The map at left shows the distribution of ozone in the atmosphere on July 14th and 15th, 2000, measured by the Total Ozone Mapping Spectrometer (TOMS). (Image courtesy TOMS science team)

Jackman explains that ultraviolet radiation from the sun continuously strikes the upper atmosphere. These harmful ultraviolet rays would make life on Earth impossible if it weren’t for the ozone layer that absorbs the radiation. Ozone forms when three atoms of oxygen bind together to create a single molecule (O₃), but when ozone absorbs ultraviolet radiation, the molecules split apart into a single free oxygen atom, and an oxygen molecule of two tightly bound oxygen atoms (O₂). O₂ is the oxygen we breathe, and it makes up about 21 percent of the Earth’s air.

“The free oxygen atom is so reactive and there is so much O₂ around, that out of 1001 times that this reaction occurs, 1000 times it will reform,” Jackman says. As a result, day-to-day break down of ozone by ultraviolet radiation doesn’t affect the overall amount of it in the atmosphere. “The only way to destroy ozone is for that free atom of oxygen to reform with something else,” Jackman says.

That’s where solar proton events enter the picture. When protons from the sun hit the atmosphere they break apart both water vapor and nitrogen gas, which accounts for 78 percent of our atmosphere. The nitrogen gas molecules (N₂) disconnect and leave two free nitrogen atoms. Nitrogen atoms are highly reactive with O₂, creating oxides of nitrogen. Once formed, these molecules can last for weeks to months depending on where they end up in the atmosphere before they get destroyed. Protons also break up water vapor (H₂0) into a hydroxide molecule (OH) and a free-floating single atom of hydrogen. Both of these products also react easily with ozone and reduce its levels in the atmosphere. Fortunately, oxides of hydrogen are short-lived and only stay together as long as the rain of protons keeps coming.

For more information about the formation and destruction of ozone, and the structure of the atmosphere, see Ozone in the Stratosphere.

Solar flare from LASCO

Jackman says that knowledge of solar protons entering the atmosphere and disrupting ozone production is not anything new. “We knew that these protons were streaming into the atmosphere,” he says. “The prediction from a few decades ago was that these protons would create free nitrogen atoms. They knew that from lab experiments.”

Scientists like Jackman regularly try to improve their computer models to more accurately simulate the atmosphere, and, in this case, to better determine present ozone levels and to predict future amounts. In order to do that, they must account for daily, short-term and long-term variations caused by different factors. “Solar proton events help us test our models,” Jackman says. That’s because they offer quick, verifiable results that can then be used to test model-based predictions.

Jackman says that prior to his study scientists had good measurements of ozone levels during solar storms, but they didn’t have as comprehensive a measurement for the effect that protons have on nitrogen oxides (NO and NO₂). This study documents actual levels of destruction, by taking readings of ozone and nitrogen oxide levels before and during the event. “Every ninety minutes, we had a new measurement of nitrogen oxides, so we could watch them develop as the solar proton event developed,” Jackman said. Scientifically speaking, the change in the amounts of nitrogen oxides and ozone was huge in the uppermost regions where ozone lies. And those were the areas where the computer models had some inaccuracies, Jackman said. Most of the damage is done near the top of the atmosphere because it takes a lot of energy for protons to penetrate to lower atmospheric regions. Fortunately for us, much less ozone exists at these heights.

Based on his prior experience with protons and ozone, when the solar storm broke on July 14 and Jackman saw the huge proton fluxes measured by another NOAA satellite, he says that he knew right away this was a unique opportunity to gather data. “The big solar storms don’t really occur that often, and this event was off the charts,” he says. “So we knew if we looked we’d have something.”

The sudden onset of a high energy proton blast from a solar flare is captured by the Large Angle Spectrometric Coronagraph (LASCO) C3 instrument on board the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) on July 14, 2000. The particles reached the spacecraft in less than one half hour and continued pelting it for days. The snow-like white spots are the protons hitting the spacecraft’s imager. Solar flares are explosions on the Sun that happen when energy stored in twisted magnetic fields (usually above sunspots) is suddenly released. (Image courtesy of the SOHO/LASCO consortium.)

Images of proton flux

The atmosphere’s layers include the troposphere, the stratosphere, the mesosphere and the thermosphere. The troposphere lies closest to Earth at zero to nine miles up, and the thermosphere floats furthest away at about 60 miles up. Ozone is distributed over these layers. About 90 percent lies within the stratosphere, and most of that amount-over 80 percent of the total ozone-stays in the middle and lower stratospheric regions. Around 9 percent can be found in the troposphere, and the remaining one percent sits in the mesosphere.

By observing the Bastille Day solar event, Jackman and his colleagues found that the short-term effects of hydrogen oxides destroyed up to 70 percent of the ozone in the middle mesosphere. “The mesosphere was really shaken,” Jackman says. At the same time, ozone loss caused by longer-term nitrogen oxides cut out close to nine percent of the ozone in the upper stratosphere. But, Jackman says, only a few percent of total ozone resides in the mesosphere and upper stratosphere.

“If you look at the total atmospheric column, from your head on up to the top of the atmosphere, this solar proton event depleted less than one percent of the total ozone in the Northern Hemisphere,” Jackman said. While that doesn’t sound like a lot, scientifically speaking the numbers for the specific atmospheric regions are quite significant.

“This is an instance where we have a huge natural variance,” Jackman says. “The ultimate goal of a lot of our work is to understand the human impacts on ozone. In order to do that, you have to first be able to separate the natural effects on ozone.”
References:
Jackman, C. H.; McPeters, R. D.; Labow, G. J.; Fleming, E. L.; Praderas, C. J.; Russell, J. M., Northern Hemisphere atmospheric effects due to the July 2000 solar proton event, Geophysical Research Letters, August 1, 2000 (Vol. 28, No. 15, p. 2883)

The image sequence and graph above show the arrival of massive numbers of protons from the Bastille day solar flare. The top row of images show the crescent Earth on July 14, 2000, from the Visible Imaging System aboard the Polar spacecraft. The first image (left) was taken at 10:33 UTC, each succesive image was acquired at 7 to 8 minute intervals, with the last image taken at 11:32 UTC. The oncoming wave of protons hitting the sensor caused the increasing amount of noise (white dots) in the image sequence. The graph below shows proton flux from the same time period, measured by the High Energy Proton and Alpha Detector aboard GOES 8 (a NOAA weather satellite). The density of high-energy protons rose from less than 1 protons per square centimeter per second per steradian to over 9. This was just the beginning—on July 15 over 800 protons were counted per second. (Images courtesy International Solar-Terrestrial Physics, graph by Robert Simmon, based on data from the Space Physics Interactive Data Resource)

Subscribe to the Earth Observatory
About the Earth Observatory
Please send comments or questions to: eobweb@eob.gsfc.nasa.gov
Responsible NASA official: Yoram Kaufman


	Atmospheric scientist Charles Jackman and a team of researchers from NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center and Hampton University in Virginia recognized a rare opportunity to gather further proof that solar storms destroy ozone. They already knew that when protons bombard the upper atmosphere, they break up molecules of gases like nitrogen and water vapor. Once freed, those products readily react with ozone molecules and reduce the ozone layer. So, Jackman and his colleagues recalled specific Northern Hemisphere atmospheric data from NASA and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) satellites that continuously monitor the composition of gases and molecules that surround our planet. Their findings, published in the August 1, 2001, issue of Geophysical Research Letters, show that less than one percent of total atmospheric ozone in the Northern Hemisphere can be quickly reduced by one of these events. “It is an indication of the power of the sun to actually affect the atmosphere in a sudden, cataclysmic way,” Jackman says. While the results do not show a significant impact on human health, especially considering that most of the ozone loss documented in this study occurs over the northern polar region, they are important scientifically. The study gives detailed and quantified knowledge of how a solar storm affects upper-level ozone. As scientists race to better understand humankind’s role in ozone loss, they must first be able to tease out the natural causes.		On July 14th, 2000, an active region of the sun (called AR9077) produced a massive flare. The event also blasted an enormous cloud of positive-charged particles toward planet Earth, triggering magnetic storms and dramatic auroral displays. This striking close-up of AR9077 was made by the orbiting Transition Region and Coronal Explorer (TRACE) satellite shortly after the flare erupted. Suspended in an arcade of magnetic loops, the image shows a one million degree hot solar plasma cooling down. Plasma is a gas that has been heated to a state where it contains ions and free-floating electrons. The false-color image covers an expansive 230,000 by 77,000 kilometer area on the Sun’s surface (Earth’s diameter is about 12,800 kilometers) and was recorded in extreme ultraviolet light. Collectively resembling a popular “slinky” toy, the enormous loops are actually magnetic field lines which trap the glowing, cooling plasma above the relatively dark solar surface. After the flare, AR9077’s activity decayed as it was carried farther across the Earth-facing hemisphere of the Sun by solar rotation. Active regions like AR9077 appear as groups of dark sunspots in visible light. (Image courtesy TRACE)
	“A lot of impacts on ozone, like those caused by humans, are very subtle and happen over long periods of time,” says Jackman. “But when these solar proton events occur you can see immediately a change in the atmosphere.”		The map at left shows the distribution of ozone in the atmosphere on July 14th and 15th, 2000, measured by the Total Ozone Mapping Spectrometer (TOMS). (Image courtesy TOMS science team)
	Jackman explains that ultraviolet radiation from the sun continuously strikes the upper atmosphere. These harmful ultraviolet rays would make life on Earth impossible if it weren’t for the ozone layer that absorbs the radiation. Ozone forms when three atoms of oxygen bind together to create a single molecule (O₃), but when ozone absorbs ultraviolet radiation, the molecules split apart into a single free oxygen atom, and an oxygen molecule of two tightly bound oxygen atoms (O₂). O₂ is the oxygen we breathe, and it makes up about 21 percent of the Earth’s air. “The free oxygen atom is so reactive and there is so much O₂ around, that out of 1001 times that this reaction occurs, 1000 times it will reform,” Jackman says. As a result, day-to-day break down of ozone by ultraviolet radiation doesn’t affect the overall amount of it in the atmosphere. “The only way to destroy ozone is for that free atom of oxygen to reform with something else,” Jackman says. That’s where solar proton events enter the picture. When protons from the sun hit the atmosphere they break apart both water vapor and nitrogen gas, which accounts for 78 percent of our atmosphere. The nitrogen gas molecules (N₂) disconnect and leave two free nitrogen atoms. Nitrogen atoms are highly reactive with O₂, creating oxides of nitrogen. Once formed, these molecules can last for weeks to months depending on where they end up in the atmosphere before they get destroyed. Protons also break up water vapor (H₂0) into a hydroxide molecule (OH) and a free-floating single atom of hydrogen. Both of these products also react easily with ozone and reduce its levels in the atmosphere. Fortunately, oxides of hydrogen are short-lived and only stay together as long as the rain of protons keeps coming.		For more information about the formation and destruction of ozone, and the structure of the atmosphere, see Ozone in the Stratosphere.

	Jackman says that knowledge of solar protons entering the atmosphere and disrupting ozone production is not anything new. “We knew that these protons were streaming into the atmosphere,” he says. “The prediction from a few decades ago was that these protons would create free nitrogen atoms. They knew that from lab experiments.” Scientists like Jackman regularly try to improve their computer models to more accurately simulate the atmosphere, and, in this case, to better determine present ozone levels and to predict future amounts. In order to do that, they must account for daily, short-term and long-term variations caused by different factors. “Solar proton events help us test our models,” Jackman says. That’s because they offer quick, verifiable results that can then be used to test model-based predictions. Jackman says that prior to his study scientists had good measurements of ozone levels during solar storms, but they didn’t have as comprehensive a measurement for the effect that protons have on nitrogen oxides (NO and NO₂). This study documents actual levels of destruction, by taking readings of ozone and nitrogen oxide levels before and during the event. “Every ninety minutes, we had a new measurement of nitrogen oxides, so we could watch them develop as the solar proton event developed,” Jackman said. Scientifically speaking, the change in the amounts of nitrogen oxides and ozone was huge in the uppermost regions where ozone lies. And those were the areas where the computer models had some inaccuracies, Jackman said. Most of the damage is done near the top of the atmosphere because it takes a lot of energy for protons to penetrate to lower atmospheric regions. Fortunately for us, much less ozone exists at these heights. Based on his prior experience with protons and ozone, when the solar storm broke on July 14 and Jackman saw the huge proton fluxes measured by another NOAA satellite, he says that he knew right away this was a unique opportunity to gather data. “The big solar storms don’t really occur that often, and this event was off the charts,” he says. “So we knew if we looked we’d have something.”		The sudden onset of a high energy proton blast from a solar flare is captured by the Large Angle Spectrometric Coronagraph (LASCO) C3 instrument on board the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) on July 14, 2000. The particles reached the spacecraft in less than one half hour and continued pelting it for days. The snow-like white spots are the protons hitting the spacecraft’s imager. Solar flares are explosions on the Sun that happen when energy stored in twisted magnetic fields (usually above sunspots) is suddenly released. (Image courtesy of the SOHO/LASCO consortium.)